The One Parenting Book That Should Come with a Warning: Do Not Try This at Home!

As a child therapist I am constantly hearing about new parenting philosophies, trends and approaches. After fifteen years, most of them sound pretty similar.

The only parenting book that had me wishing it had a warning label that read DON'T TRY THIS AT HOME!

Recently I have gotten on this kick of getting the audio version of the most popular parenting books out there. I figured I had a 90 minute commute three days a week – why not fill the void with more knowledge.


The first two books filled me with fresh ideas and a new vigor to soak up learning. After all – even a seasoned child therapist and mom of three can learn a few new things!


I listened to Ross Greene’s audio version of The Explosive Child – and quickly put it at the top of my “must read” recommendations for parents. I also listened to Tamar Chansky’s Freeing Your Child from Anxiety and found myself awed at the amount of wonderful and insightful advice she offered parents. A definite must-read for any parent with anxious children!


My thirst for knowledge came to a screeching halt as I listened to Amy McCready’s If I Have to Tell You One More Time. Her extremely popular free webinar is all over the Internet – so when a parent told me they had taken the webinar and found it helpful – I was all in.


Unlike the other two books – my heart sank as I listened to the first few chapters. After an hour into the audiobook I had a growing list of parenting behavior that was not acceptable and harmful to my child.


I went home and found myself tripping over my words as I tried to parent my children for the next few days.


I could no longer tell my child, “good job” without feeling a ton of guilt – as the author said I could be damaging my child.


I choked and stumbled on my sentence as I caught myself telling my child, “I am proud of you.” I was told that to use such words is judging my child.


When my daughter was showing me her math score I literally took back my compliment, “You are so good at math!” and quickly replaced it with the more effective parenting sentence, “You worked hard at math and therefore you got a good grade.” My child just looked at me with confusion and walked away.


What is wrong with mommy – they must be thinking.


The book should come with a warning, “Don’t try this at home” – as I was becoming more ineffective than I ever had been – double guessing and triple guessing my parental interactions.


I thought – if this can make me feel overwhelmed – what could it do to some of the more anxious or self-critical parents I work with in my practice?


As I trudged through the book – I was left with many great tips and some wonderful reminders. The author has summarized some very popular parenting approaches in a very succinct and effective manner. There was nothing new in the book, but it repackaged and renamed some very sound advice. I loved the suggestion of extra time with your children and I love positive parenting approaches in general.


So why was I not feeling so positive after listening to this book?



With social media, we cannot escape the strongly opinionated professionals and parents who love to tell you what you are doing wrong and how you should be doing it better. Luckily there is some backlash out there – with a strong message to end parent shaming.


As a child therapist and writer – I want to boost people up, not tear them down. I realize that giving people “should nots” will do nothing to encourage positive parenting and everything to make them doubt their abilities. Parents can be taught positive parenting approaches with grace, acceptance and soft guidance.


I know I might be extra sensitive and so perhaps I took the do nots a little too deeply. But I know that I am not alone. I have had many parents proudly tell me they do not “praise” their children. I understand the author’s intentions around this topic – and they make sense, but the meaning may have gotten lost with this all or nothing message.


I am sorry, but I do not think that if I tell my child “good job” or “you are great at math” that I am doing irrevocable harm. Would it be better to highlight what they did well – of course. Would it be great to outline their hard work and effort – definitely. Am I a bad parent if sometimes that doesn’t come out of my mouth. I think not. And I am here to tell you- you are not either.

Visit Anxious Toddlers’s profile on Pinterest.

6 responses to “The One Parenting Book That Should Come with a Warning: Do Not Try This at Home!”

  1. I like Carol Dweck’s approach of trying to lean toward a GROWTH mindset (“you worked hard) vs. a set mindset (“you are smart”) because it really allows people to change and not judge themselves. But the shaming approach never works! For parents OR kids!
    Full Spectrum Mama recently posted…FULL FRONTAL – A NEURO-MOMENTMy Profile

    • Natasha Daniels says:

      I completely agree – I like that approach much better. I think it was the harsh tone in which it was discussed that bothered me. I think we are all trying to do our very best – and if we slip up and “praise” our children in a way that doesn’t facilitate growth – we are not judging our kids – we are just trying to let them know they are doing great :-).

  2. I beat myself up all the time over what I should have said, not said, should have done, not done with my kids. As a teacher, I used to do it with my students too. I try really hard to remember what a good mommy friend told me, “Any mom who’s researching, reading, analyzing her language and thinking about interactions with her child as much as you are must not be doing too bad of a job.” It does make me smile and give myself a little bit of a break. 🙂

  3. Natasha, I found this post via Pinterest and I’m so glad I hopped over here to read it! I think it’s important for us to get input from others into our parenting, perhaps to reveal blind spots we hadn’t noticed. Well and good. But in my opinion, guides and authors who shake our confidence in our own mama-instinct and common sense aren’t helping long-term. Perhaps books like that sell because they seem like “new revelation”. And perhaps your client who found it “helpful” really meant that she read a lot of stuff she figured she must need since it was so different from what she’d heard anywhere else (or so different from what she was naturally inclined to do). Thanks for this thoughtful post!

    • Natasha Daniels says:

      Thanks for your insightful comment Lynna. I agree with you. Getting support and advice from others is great, but when it tears you down and makes you doubt your natural instinct, that’s more harmful than helpful.

      It is hard enough being a mom these days – we need all the encouragement we can get! Thanks for stopping by 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

WordPress spam blocked by CleanTalk.